If you’re facing criminal charges or involved in a criminal case in Ontario, you may have heard of a recantation letter. Whether you’re a witness, the accused, or a legal professional, understanding how recanting a statement works—and its potential consequences is essential.
What is a Recantation Letter in Criminal Law?
A recantation letter is a formal written statement in which a witness withdraws or alters a previous statement made to law enforcement. This could happen for various reasons: the original statement may have been inaccurate, made under pressure, misunderstood, or even fabricated.
But here’s the catch: Recanting a statement isn’t as simple as saying, “I take it back.” In Ontario criminal law, courts treat these letters with great caution—and often skepticism.
Can a Recantation Letter Get Criminal Charges Dropped in Ontario?
Not necessarily. Even if a witness changes or withdraws their statement, the Crown may still proceed with prosecution.
However, a professionally drafted recantation letter can significantly influence key aspects of the legal process, such as:
✅ Bail Hearings – If the case heavily depends on a witness’s original statement, a recantation may help strengthen a bail application.
✅ Plea Bargaining – The defense may leverage the recantation to negotiate a lesser charge or even a withdrawal.
✅ Trial Strategy – Recantations can be used to challenge the credibility of the original evidence and raise reasonable doubt.
Is Recanting a Statement Illegal?
No, recanting is not illegal but lying is.
If a witness falsely recants a truthful statement or admits to having lied earlier, they could be charged with perjury or public mischief. That’s why legal guidance is crucial before writing or submitting a recantation letter in Ontario.
How to Write a Recantation Letter in Ontario
A valid and credible recantation letter should be:
Truthful – Never fabricate or distort information.
Detailed – Clearly explain what parts of the original statement were incorrect and why.
Voluntary – It must not be influenced by threats, bribes, or external pressure.
Pro Tip: Always consult a criminal defence lawyer before submitting a recantation letter. A poorly written letter could harm your case more than help it.
Final Thoughts: Proceed With Caution
In Ontario, a recantation letter can change the course of a criminal case but it’s also a legal risk if done improperly. If you’re considering recanting a police statement or dealing with a witness who wants to recant, speak to an experienced Ontario criminal lawyer first.
Need Advice 📞 (519) 259-1447 ? At Adlai Law, we specialize in criminal defence across Ontario. Contact us for a confidential consultation.
📬 Have questions about recantation letters in Ontario criminal cases? Drop a comment below or send us a DM—we’re here to help.